Whenever a sanitary landfill is discussed in Costa Rica, the conversation tends to move quickly toward the question of where it will be located. But in Turrúcares, the debate has raised a more uncomfortable question: if the country keeps depending on burying what it consumes, how much longer can it do so without some community paying the price?

The Parlamento Cívico Ambiental (PCA) spoke out against this project and, in doing so, put the focus on the entire waste management model, not just on a plot of land. This article explains what is at stake, what mechanisms are part of the discussion, and what all of this means for anyone who separates, or doesn’t separate, their trash at home.

What a sanitary landfill is and why it provokes resistance

A sanitary landfill is a facility designed to dispose of non-recoverable waste in a controlled way. The idea is that the material remains confined, with systems aimed at reducing the impacts on soil, air and water. The term “sanitary” refers to those controls, but it does not eliminate the risk: leachate (liquids generated as garbage decomposes) and gases require permanent monitoring during operation and long after closure.

That is why opposition usually centers on a few recurring issues: proximity to water sources, the effect on the health of people living nearby, and the quality of life in the surrounding area. According to the PCA, these are precisely the concerns of the Turrúcares communities, which have been organized against the project for more than a decade, as reported by Delfino.cr.

What is at stake in the Turrúcares case

According to the sources, the project is promoted by the company EBI on the Bajo Pita estate, in San Miguel de Turrúcares, Alajuela. El Mundo CR presents it under the name “Parque de Tecnología Ambiental” (Environmental Technology Park).

The point that has generated the most reaction is the link between public works and the project. Delfino.cr reports that, during a public forum on November 4, the Minister of the Presidency and Finance, Rodrigo Chaves Robles, conditioned investments in roads, bridges, a technical professional high school, a Cen-Cinai child care center, and centers for older adults on the Alajuela Municipal Council withdrawing the legal actions seeking to annul the land-use certificates for the project.

According to the same source, the minister argued that this withdrawal would make it possible to negotiate the termination of an international arbitration against Costa Rica brought by the Canadian company Berthier EBI and its affiliate Bajo Pita S. A. However, no signed agreement guaranteeing the withdrawal from the arbitration was presented at that meeting. Delfino.cr also notes that the Partido Pueblo Soberano caucus rejected, on November 9, a motion to condemn the minister’s actions, and that on November 16 the Office of the Attorney General of the Republic (Fiscalía General de la República) confirmed the opening of a criminal case for the alleged crime of influence peddling. These are data reported by that source; this article does not add interpretations of them.

For the reader, the mechanism is clear: the local government has authority over land use, and the conflict lies in how those powers relate to national investment decisions. The PCA called for respect for municipal autonomy and for citizen participation in land-use planning decisions, and argued that the needs of communities should not be used as pressure to favor business interests.

The underlying argument: a model that is running out

Beyond this specific case, the PCA argues that Turrúcares shows the exhaustion of a national model centered on collecting, transporting and burying waste. Its central message is that Costa Rica cannot keep solving the problem by looking for new territories to dump garbage, shifting the impact from one community to another.

It is worth understanding the logic of the waste hierarchy, the framework the organization invokes. In general terms, options are ranked from most to least desirable: reduce what is generated, reuse, recycle, recover (recovering energy or materials in a controlled way) and, only at the end, dispose of what has no other destination. A system that concentrates almost everything on the last step leaves little room for the earlier ones, and that pushes the search for land that is increasingly difficult to obtain.

The PCA cites Law 8839 as the basis for moving toward integrated management, and El Mundo CR summarizes its position: the law prioritizes reduction, reuse, recycling and recovery over final disposal in landfills.

What the PCA concretely proposes

The organization listed priority actions, which are better read as a roadmap than as a detailed plan:

What is interesting about this list is that it does not remove the landfill from the equation, but it places it at the end of a chain. Its success depends on the earlier stages working, which is measured in habits, municipal infrastructure and markets for recovered materials.

What it means for those who live with the garbage

For a family, the difference between one model and another is felt in everyday life. Separating at the source means having differentiated containers and a collection service that picks up that separation; without that second part, the household effort is lost in the truck. Composting, for its part, turns food and garden scraps into a useful material and reduces the organic fraction that reaches landfills, where it decomposes generating leachate and gases.

News sources