A few weeks ago, it seemed unlikely that the presidents of China, Russia and the United States would share the same table. Now, according to Europa Press, China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs has confirmed a trilateral summit with Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump for Thursday, November 19, in Shenzhen. The news raises a broader question: what can three leaders with such different, and in some cases opposing, agendas negotiate?
This article does not repeat the announcement. Instead, it explains how a meeting like this is organized, what interests are at stake, and which part of the agenda is still undefined.
What has been confirmed and within what framework
According to Europa Press and Infobae, the Chinese foreign ministry announced that the summit will take place on November 19. DW Español specifies that it will be held within the framework of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum summit in Shenzhen, and that the trilateral meeting would begin at 14:30 local time. This detail matters: the meeting is not an isolated summit, but a moment within a multilateral agenda that was already scheduled.
DW also reports that Putin plans to hold bilateral meetings with the host, Xi, and with Trump, in addition to the joint meeting. In other words, there will be at least three separate conversations, not just a group photo.
What each party says
The Kremlin, through its foreign policy adviser Yuri Ushakov, cited by Infobae, described a dialogue that is “useful and substantive” and that should have a “great impact” on the international situation. From Beijing, spokesperson Mao Ning spoke of “in-depth exchanges” on world peace and strategic stability among major powers, and described the event as one of “historic importance,” according to DW.
The White House was more cautious. According to DW, it indicated that the conversation will focus on reducing strategic arsenals, but it lowered expectations of immediate results. Trump, for his part, said that “many things” will be discussed and mentioned the war in Iran. This difference in tone between the Kremlin and Washington is, in itself, a clue about the kind of agreement each side considers realistic.
Two agendas at one table
The meeting brings together topics that, in practice, are very different. On one hand is arms control, that is, how to limit or reduce nuclear and strategic arsenals. On the other, there are specific conflicts: the war in Ukraine, which according to DW Español, citing The Wall Street Journal, was the very reason behind the idea of the summit, and the war in Iran, which Trump mentioned.
This mix is key to understanding the risk of excessive expectations. An arms agreement requires technical details, verification and commitments that are negotiated over months. A ceasefire or a political rapprochement can be faster, but not necessarily lasting. Sources agree that, for now, no one is clear on which specific issues will be addressed.
What the photo means for each country
For Russia, according to the analysis reported by DW, a trilateral meeting with an official photograph would be a diplomatic victory. Moscow has faced years of isolation from Kyiv’s allies since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, which began in February 2022.
For the United States, the image is more delicate. Trump has already had public engagements with Xi and Putin during his second term, but sitting with both at the same time can be read in different ways at home and abroad.
China is perhaps the most complex case. It shares broad alignment with Russia on several international issues, but it seeks to avoid being seen as linked to the war in Ukraine and to project the image of a responsible actor. Moreover, according to DW, it is trying to rebuild its economic relationship with the European Union, and for Europe it would be difficult to accept that Ukraine is discussed at a summit hosted by Beijing without the presence of Kyiv or Brussels. El País, for its part, describes Xi arriving at the APEC summit at a moment of greater global weight and with a broader network of support in Asia, Africa and Latin America.
Why it is compared to Yalta
According to DW, the media already speak of a “new Yalta.” The reference is to the 1945 conference in which the United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union discussed how to divide power in the postwar period. The comparison works as a headline, but it has limits. Yalta was a negotiation among powers reorganizing Europe after a world war. Today the situation is different: there are other actors, multilateral institutions and conflicts that cannot be resolved solely among three capitals.
According to ECFR researcher Alicja Bachulska, cited by DW, Beijing is aware of the negative connotations of the comparison, although it considers it historically inaccurate. It is worth keeping this in mind: the way a meeting is labeled also influences how other countries perceive it.
What we still do not know
The available sources leave several questions open: which concrete agreements could come out of the meeting, whether documents will be signed, how the war in Ukraine will be addressed without Kyiv’s presence, and whether the agenda will include other topics. It also remains to be seen how time will be divided between the bilateral meetings and the trilateral encounter.
For now, what is confirmed is the date, the location, the APEC framework and the existence of planned conversations among the three leaders. Everything else belongs, for the time being, to the realm of expectations.
The essentials
- China has confirmed a trilateral summit between Xi, Putin and Trump on November 19 in Shenzhen, within the framework of APEC.
- The Kremlin and Beijing speak of a meeting of great impact and historic importance; the White House lowered expectations of immediate results.
- The official agenda mentions the reduction of strategic arsenals, although the wars in Ukraine and Iran are also cited.
News sources
- Europa Press: China confirms that Xi, Trump and Putin will hold their trilateral summit on November 19 in Shenzhen
- DW Español: An Awkward Photo for Beijing: Xi, Trump and Putin at a Tripartite Summit
- Infobae América: Russia believes the Putin-Trump-Xi meeting will have a "great impact" on the world
- Infobae América: China confirms that Xi, Trump and Putin will hold a trilateral summit on November 19 in Shenzhen
- El País: Xi Jinping hosts the Asia-Pacific summit at the height of his power in China and with growing global weight