For years, the board of directors of Banco Popular has been a low-profile topic for the general public. Today it is not. A constitutional challenge seeks to end the Executive Branch’s final say over the directors chosen by the bank’s workers. To understand what is at stake, one must look at both the appeal and the design of the board, as well as the decree that left it without its full composition.
What the lawsuit requests
According to Semanario Universidad, the action was filed by Rafael López, former delegate of the Workers’ Assembly of Banco Popular y de Desarrollo Comunal. The appeal targets the phrase “y ratificados por el Poder Ejecutivo” (“and ratified by the Executive Branch”) in article 15, subsection b), of the Organic Law of Banco Popular y de Desarrollo Comunal, Law No. 4351. If the Constitutional Chamber (Sala Constitucional) agreed with him, that part of the law would be removed.
The central argument is that the Executive’s veto replaces the will of the Workers’ Assembly with a political decision that is not provided for in the law’s representation mechanisms. López maintains that the bank belongs to its workers and that, for this reason, the designation of their representatives should be respected. According to the appeal, the Constitutional Chamber has recognized the bank as a “non-state public law institution, owned by its workers.” Semanario Universidad also notes that the appeal invokes institutional autonomy, democratic representation, reasonableness, proportionality, and legal certainty.
On the argument about financial stability, López responds that a political veto is unnecessary, because CONASSIF already has suitability criteria for those who hold these positions. In his reading, the Executive’s intervention unjustifiably limits the corporate governance autonomy that the legislator intended.
How the board is structured
The law establishes a seven-member board: three appointed by the Executive Branch and four designated by the Workers’ Assembly. The four from the Assembly must be ratified by the government, and this is the point the lawsuit challenges.
La Nación’s editorial, which is opinion and not news, notes that the Attorney General’s Office (Procuraduría) has classified the bank as a non-state public entity. According to that same text, the law prevents the Executive or any other body from imposing decisions on the custody, administration, or investment of workers’ savings. This balance between directors from the Assembly and from the Executive is what the appeal considers unbalanced: the veto, it argues, functions as a political filter over a decision that belongs to the owners.
The decree that changed the board
The debate is not limited to the lawsuit. According to La Nación, Banco Popular has not had a board of directors since July 31. A decree published on November 9 allows the Government Council to appoint all seven directors, including the four that the law reserves for the Assembly, on a temporary basis. The government justifies this on the grounds that, without a board, it cannot approve the 2027 budget, hire the external audit, or fulfill non-delegable functions.
La Nación points out a detail that weighs heavily in the discussion: the decree sets no end date and will remain in force while the integration of the Workers’ Assembly for the 2026-2030 period is completed. The editorial suggests that the natural solution would be to speed up that integration rather than replace it. This is an editorial position, not a verified fact, and it should be read as such.
There is another layer worth examining. Delfino.cr reported, according to its headline, that the Workers’ Assembly sent the Executive its shortlist of pre-selected candidates for the board. The available information does not show whether this step changes the scenario created by the decree or how the government is assessing it.
The 2022 precedent
To understand why financial stability sits at the center of the debate, it is worth reviewing what La Nación recalls about 2022. According to the editorial, then-president Rodrigo Chaves decreed full control over the bank for eight months, and that control extended throughout his entire administration. During that period, Sugef classified the bank as being in financial irregularity due to weaknesses in corporate governance, including the suitability of its directors, and recommended the removal of the board’s president.
The bank exited that condition in September, although with reservations about the composition of the board. Sugef ordered it to submit an action plan that must be approved by the National Board of Directors (Junta Directiva Nacional), a body that has not yet been formed. This precedent explains why both sides use the same argument: some see supervision as the reason for intervention, while others see it as proof that intervention does not always improve governance.
Why it matters to those who do not work at the bank
News sources
- Semanario Universidad: Constitutional challenge seeks to prevent the government from having to ratify board members of Banco Popular
- La Nación Costa Rica: Editorial: Banco Popular: seven seats, one single will: the government’s
- Delfino.cr: Workers’ Assembly sent the Executive its shortlist of pre-selected candidates for the Banco Popular Board of Directors